Chapter 6 - THE WOMAN WHO USED MY NAMEI asked Dr. Fairchild to repeat himself.
He did.
“Someone appeared at my office approximately four months ago and identified herself as Elaine Hale.”
Michael was beside me at the kitchen counter.
I placed the phone on speaker.
“What did she look like?”
There was hesitation.
“I’d prefer to discuss this in person.”
“Why?”
“Because there are documents involved, and I’ve already notified our legal counsel.”
Michael glanced at me.
“Doctor, are you saying someone signed medical documents under my wife’s name?”
“Yes.”
We drove to New York that afternoon.
Three hours on the highway gave me too much time to think.
Beverly called twice.
Mom called seven times.
I answered neither.
Dad sent one text.
I’m at a hotel. I love you. I’m sorry I didn’t see what was happening.
That message hurt more than Mom’s calls.
Michael drove with one hand and held mine with the other whenever traffic allowed.
“You don’t have to protect me from whatever we find,” I said.
“I know.”
“You’re doing that thing.”
“What thing?”
“The calm thing.”
“I am calm.”
“You reorganized our entire kitchen at two in the morning.”
“The spices were chaos.”
“You alphabetized paprika.”
“It begins with P.”
Despite everything, I laughed.
That was Michael.
He never performed courage.
He created order.
Dr. Fairchild’s office occupied two floors of a glass building overlooking the East River.
His attorney joined the meeting.
So did the clinic administrator.
That told me immediately how serious it was.
Dr. Robert Fairchild was about sixty, silver-haired and visibly uncomfortable.
He placed a folder on the conference table.
“Before we proceed, I want to apologize. Our identification procedures were not sufficient.”
I opened the folder.
The first page contained my name.
Elaine Marie Hale.
My birth date.
My old address.
My medical history.
Then I saw a scanned driver’s license.
My face.
But not my license.
The photograph had been taken from a professional headshot.
The document was counterfeit.
Michael swore under his breath.
Dr. Fairchild continued.
“The woman who attended the consultation said she was considering directed egg donation to her sister.”
“What did she look like?”
He pulled up a security still.
My mother.
There was no question.
Margaret Hale sat in the clinic waiting room wearing oversized sunglasses and a scarf.
For several seconds, I simply stared.
Michael’s hand closed over mine.
My voice came out flat.
“That’s my mother.”
The attorney began taking notes.
Dr. Fairchild looked deeply uncomfortable.
“She represented herself as you for approximately forty minutes.”
“What did she say?”
“She discussed your medical history and underwent counseling concerning donor considerations.”
“Did you examine her?”
“No. No medical procedure occurred. The appointment was informational.”
A small mercy.
“Why would she pretend to be me rather than just send the records?”
“There are ethical restrictions around evaluating potential donors without their participation. We told Mrs. Cole we could not proceed unless the proposed donor consented.”
I understood.
“So Mom became the consenting donor.”
“Yes.”
Michael’s jaw clenched.
“How far did this go?”
“Not far. We requested additional testing. She said she wanted time to think. Nothing further occurred.”
I turned the pages.
There were handwritten notes.
One line was underlined:
Patient expresses strong commitment to helping sister create a family.
I felt tears in my eyes.
My mother had placed words in my mouth.
Not just accessed my life.
Authored it.
“Did Beverly attend?”
Dr. Fairchild nodded.
“Yes.”
I closed the folder.
So Beverly had known.
All of it.
“Can I have copies?”
“Our counsel has prepared everything we can legally provide.”
The attorney slid another folder toward us.
Michael asked, “Have you contacted law enforcement?”
“We reported suspected identity fraud this morning.”
My stomach tightened.
It was one thing to say my mother crossed a line.
Another to hear the word fraud.
On the drive back to Boston, Beverly finally left a voicemail.
“Elaine, please call me before you go to the police. Mom did something stupid, but she did it for me. If you report this, you’re going to destroy our family.”
I listened twice.
Then deleted it.
Our family had not been destroyed by reporting what happened.
It had been damaged by what happened.
There was a difference I was only beginning to understand.
That evening, Ryan appeared at our apartment.
He looked exhausted.
“Can I come in?”
Michael looked at me.
I nodded.
Ryan sat at the kitchen table.
For years I had considered him pleasant but distant.
Beverly dominated rooms.
Ryan often seemed happy to let her.
Now he looked like someone waking after a long illness.
“I moved out.”
I wasn’t surprised.
“I’m sorry.”
“I don’t know whether we’re done.”
“That’s between you two.”
He nodded.
Then placed an envelope on the table.
“There’s something you need to see.”
I didn’t want another document.
I was beginning to hate paper.
Inside were printed emails.
Between Beverly and Mom.
The earliest was fourteen months old.
Before my first fertility appointment.
I read.
Mom: Elaine says she and Michael might start trying after the wedding.
Beverly: Of course she does.
Mom: Don’t do this.
Beverly: I’m happy for her.
Mom: You don’t sound happy.
Beverly: Because she gets everything without even trying.
My chest tightened.
Another email.
Beverly: If she gets pregnant before me, I honestly don’t know if I can handle it.
Mom: Then we don’t tell you if that happens until you’re ready.
I looked up.
“Where did these come from?”
“Beverly left her laptop at the house. She told me to bring it. Her email was open.”
Michael frowned.
“Ryan, you probably shouldn’t be accessing—”
“I know. I stopped when I realized what I was looking at. But I printed the messages mentioning Elaine.”
I continued.
After my fertility consultation:
Mom: She saw a specialist.
Beverly: How bad?
Mom: She won’t tell me.
Beverly: I can probably get into her old account.
Then:
Beverly: I found the password.
Mom: Don’t do anything stupid.
Beverly: Says the woman who wants to know too.
And days later:
Beverly: You were right. Her numbers are bad.
Mom: Are you sure?
Beverly: Read it yourself.
What followed made me sick.
My mother initially told Beverly they had to stop.
Beverly kept pushing.
Then Mom began participating.
Eventually, the language changed.
They discussed my appointments.
My lab values.
Dr. Fairchild.
Potential donation.
And one exchange three days before my follow-up:
Mom: Elaine is getting another scan Thursday.
Beverly: Then we need to decide before then.
Mom: Decide what?
Beverly: If she finds out she has options, she’ll never donate to me.
I stopped reading.
Michael said nothing.
Ryan covered his face.
I read the sentence again.
If she finds out she has options, she’ll never donate to me.
My throat closed.
“They canceled my appointment because they wanted me to believe I couldn’t have children.”
Ryan whispered, “I think so.”
Everything inside me went quiet.
Not angry.
Not sad.
Empty.
That was worse.
Beverly hadn’t merely misunderstood my report.
She had intentionally interfered with my medical care because hopelessness made me easier to manipulate.
Maybe the plan was to eventually tell me that while I couldn’t have my own child, I might be able to help her.
I stood and walked into the bathroom.
Then I vomited.
Michael sat with me on the floor afterward.
“I don’t understand,” I whispered.
“I know.”
“She’s my sister.”
“I know.”
“I would have helped her.”
“I know.”
That was the worst part.
Hours later, after Ryan left, I finally called Beverly.
She answered on the first ring.
“Elaine.”
“Did you cancel my scan because you thought I’d be more willing to donate eggs if I believed I couldn’t have children?”
Silence.
Then crying.
“Please let me explain.”
“Yes or no.”
“It wasn’t like that.”
“Yes or no.”
“I was desperate.”
I closed my eyes.
Michael sat across from me.
“That’s not an answer.”
“I thought if your prognosis was bad anyway—”
I hung up.
She called back.
I declined.
Again.
Declined.
Then messages arrived.
You don’t understand what infertility does to you.
I wasn’t thinking clearly.
Mom pushed things too.
I never meant for you to get hurt.
That last sentence made me laugh.
Because she had stood in front of four hundred people and announced the very wound she claimed she never wanted me to have.
Then another message arrived.
One that made me stop.
I’m pregnant.
I stared at the screen.
Michael saw my face.
“What?”
I handed him the phone.
Beverly sent another message.
Seven weeks.
Please don’t tell Ryan.
My heartbeat accelerated.
Michael looked at me.
“Is it Ryan’s?”
I typed exactly that.
May you like
Her answer came thirty seconds later.
No.
Related Stories
